Is Now the Right Time to Turn Your Denver Home Into a Rental Property?
Thinking About Selling? You Might Want to Read This First.
If you own a home in Denver and you're weighing your options, you're not alone. A lot of homeowners right now are caught in an awkward spot: they're not sure the sales market is working in their favor, but they also don't know if holding onto the property makes sense. What many people miss is a third option — converting that home into a rental and letting it work for you while you wait for better conditions.
At Bergan & Company, we've been managing Denver-area rental properties since 1961. Over more than six decades, we've seen sellers rush the market at the wrong time, leave money on the table, and wish they'd waited. We've also watched smart homeowners quietly build wealth by turning a property they weren't ready to sell into a steady income stream. The Denver rental market has historically rewarded that kind of patience.
What's Happening in the Denver Sales Market Right Now
The Denver real estate sales market has shifted noticeably from the frenzied pace of the early 2020s. Rising interest rates have cooled buyer demand across the metro area, and homes that once received multiple offers within days are now sitting longer. Sellers are increasingly having to make concessions — price reductions, closing cost help, and other incentives — that were nearly unheard of just a few years ago.
That doesn't mean Denver is in trouble. Far from it. The city remains one of the most desirable places to live in the country, anchored by employers in tech, aerospace, healthcare, and government along the Front Range. Neighborhoods like Washington Park, Highlands, and Stapleton continue to draw consistent interest from renters and buyers alike. The fundamentals are still strong — but sellers today need to be realistic about timing.
In our experience, homeowners who convert to rentals during softer sales markets often come out ahead. They preserve equity, generate monthly income, and retain the option to sell when conditions improve.
Why the Rental Market Tells a Different Story
Here's something worth understanding: a slower sales market often strengthens the rental market. When fewer people can afford to buy — or choose not to because of high mortgage rates — more people rent. That dynamic increases demand for quality rental homes across the Denver metro, from Aurora and Lakewood to Littleton and Thornton.
Denver also has a large population of renters who prefer single-family homes over apartments. These are often families, young professionals, or people relocating for work who want a yard, a garage, and a good school district. If your home fits that profile, you're sitting on something that the rental market genuinely wants right now.
Bergan & Company currently maintains a 95% occupancy rate across our managed portfolio and fills vacancies in an average of just 2 to 3 weeks. That kind of performance doesn't happen by accident — it reflects real, sustained demand for well-managed rental homes in this market. You can explore the 19 Denver-metro areas we serve to see if your property is in our coverage zone.
The Financial Case for Converting Instead of Selling
Let's talk practically. If you sell today into a softened market, you may net less than you would have two years ago — and significantly less than you might a few years from now if Denver's growth trajectory continues. On the other hand, if you convert your home to a rental, you can:
- Generate monthly rental income that offsets your mortgage or other expenses
- Preserve your equity rather than locking in a sale at a market low
- Take advantage of tax deductions available to rental property owners (consult your tax advisor for specifics)
- Retain the option to sell later when buyer demand and market conditions are more favorable
- Build long-term wealth through property appreciation over time
Many homeowners are also surprised to learn that professional property management is more affordable than they expected. Bergan & Company charges a straightforward 10% monthly management fee and a 50% of first month's rent leasing fee — with free lease renewals, no upfront fees, and zero termination fees with just 30 days' notice. You can review our full fee structure and plans to see exactly what you'd be working with.
What to Consider Before Converting Your Home
Converting a home to a rental isn't a decision to make lightly. There are real responsibilities that come with being a landlord in Colorado. The state has strong tenant protections, including Colorado's warranty of habitability rules, which require landlords to maintain properties in livable condition. You'll need to stay on top of maintenance, handle tenant communications, and comply with local ordinances.
That's exactly why most successful rental property owners in Denver work with a professional management company. The job of a good property manager is to handle the day-to-day details — tenant screening, lease agreements, rent collection, maintenance coordination — so you don't have to. Our delinquency rate across managed properties is just 1%, which speaks to the value of thorough tenant screening and consistent management.
- Is your mortgage (if any) structured to allow rental use? Check with your lender.
- Does your homeowner's insurance need to be converted to a landlord policy?
- Are there HOA rules that limit or restrict rental activity?
- Is the property in good condition, or does it need work before it's rent-ready?
- Do you have a local property manager you trust to handle it properly?
How Bergan & Company Can Help You Make the Right Call
We won't tell you that renting is always the right answer — it isn't. But we will tell you that too many Denver homeowners make the sell-or-rent decision without all the information they need. The first step is understanding what your property could realistically earn as a rental. That number changes everything.
Bergan & Company offers a free rental analysis for Denver-area homeowners. We'll evaluate your property, assess local rental demand in your specific neighborhood, and give you a realistic picture of what you could expect to earn each month. There's no obligation — just honest information from a team that's been doing this in Denver for over 60 years.
Whether your home is in Lakewood, Aurora, or anywhere else across the metro, we have the local knowledge and the systems to help you make a smart, informed decision. Our family has been part of this community for decades, and we take that responsibility seriously.
Not sure if renting makes sense for your Denver home? Request your free rental analysis today — no commitment, no pressure. Just real numbers from real local experts. Contact Bergan & Company to get started.
Free Rental AnalysisStay Updated on Denver Property Management
Get insights on local market trends, landlord tips, and investment strategies.
About the Author
Cody Bergan
Principal
Third-generation property management professional leading Bergan & Company with hands-on expertise in the Denver rental market.
Meet our team →Related Articles
Relocating from Denver? Here's How to Turn Your Home Into a Rental (Without the Headaches)
Relocating doesn't have to mean selling your Denver home. Learn how to convert your property into a rental, what to expect along the way, and how professional management can make the transition stress-free.
Tax Season for Denver Landlords: What Your Property Manager's Reports Should Give You
When tax season arrives, the quality of your property manager's financial reporting can make or break your return. Here's exactly what Denver landlords should expect from their management team — and what to do if those reports fall short.
How Long Does It Take to Rent Out a House in Denver? A Property Manager's Honest Answer
Wondering how long your Denver rental will sit vacant before finding a tenant? The answer depends on more than just the market — pricing, presentation, and marketing all play a major role.
